5 common misconceptions about the environmental impact of products

The Bioproductions research programme aims to overcome the scientific and technological barriers associated with converting biomass into bio-based products, in order to contribute to the transition from a fossil-fuel-based economy to a bioeconomy. Is a bio-based product necessarily better for the environment than a petroleum-based product? Is it impact-free or necessarily recyclable? To answer these questions, it is essential to assess the environmental impacts of products throughout their life cycle. Life-cycle assessment (LCA) is a method that takes into account the various stages, from the production of raw materials to the end of the product’s life. It enables solutions to be compared, the main impacts and areas for improvement to be identified, and informs strategic and policy decisions.

Here are five common misconceptions to help you better understand this tool and its value for the eco-design of bio-based products.

Misconception No. 1: a product that emits less CO₂ is necessarily better for the environment

False. A more favourable carbon footprint does not necessarily mean a lower overall environmental impact.

A product may have a favourable carbon footprint whilst consuming more water, using up more land or contributing to environmental pollution.

LCA adopts a multi-criteria assessment approach. It assesses 16 indicators of environmental impact, including: climate change, fine particulate emissions, resource depletion (water, non-renewable energy, metals, etc.), land use, eutrophication and acidification of soils and aquatic environments, and potential toxic effects on human health and ecosystems.

This approach makes it possible, in particular, to identify any potential transfer of impacts between two alternatives.

It should be noted that LCA does not cover all aspects of environmental sustainability, particularly certain local nuisances (noise, odours, etc.).

Common misconception no. 2: a bio-based product necessarily has a better environmental impact than a petroleum-based product

False. The bio-based origin of a raw material does not, in itself, guarantee a better environmental footprint.

The cultivation of plants used for bio-based products may, for example, require fertilisers and plant protection products, generating polluting emissions into the environment, and sometimes leading to additional consumption of water and energy resources. Deforestation to expand cropland can significantly increase the environmental impact. Conversely, utilising residues or co-products often helps to reduce these impacts, although they remain closely linked to the nature of the biomass used, the processing methods employed and the end uses.

LCA takes into account the entire life cycle: the extraction of raw materials, manufacturing processes, transport, distribution, use and end-of-life or recycling. It enables a comparison of different solutions offering equivalent performance and helps determine under what conditions a bio-based product constitutes a viable alternative.

Common misconception No. 3: transport is always the main environmental impact of a product

False. For a bio-based material, agricultural production, processing, use or end-of-life often have a greater impact than transport.

For example, local tomatoes grown in a gas-heated greenhouse have a much higher carbon footprint than tomatoes imported from Spain by lorry.

Furthermore, the impact of transport depends on the product’s weight and volume, the mode of transport and the distance travelled.

LCA helps to identify the stages that have the greatest impact on the environment and to determine which actions to prioritise in order to minimise it. Reducing transport distances is therefore not always the priority: optimising a process, improving energy efficiency or limiting inputs can have a greater impact.

Myth No. 4: Using a bio-based product avoids the need for petroleum-based products

This is not always true. It all depends on the actual availability of the bio-based product on the market.

Some bio-based products are co-products or recycled materials whose availability is limited by the production of the main product, rather than by demand. Additional demand cannot therefore be met by the biological resource, and will ultimately result in demand for fossil-based products.

Organic fertilisers are a good example of this. As by-products of livestock farming, their availability depends on meat and milk production. An increase in demand does not lead to more animals being reared, but rather shifts the unmet need towards synthetic mineral fertilisers.

Consequential LCA seeks to identify the effects induced by a decision or a change in production or consumption. Unlike attributional LCA, which assesses the impacts of a product within a defined system, it models shifts in equilibrium, market reactions and knock-on effects. It seeks to answer the question: “What happens if we produce or consume one more unit of this product?”

This is the objective of the BIOCaP-LCA project, supported by the PEPR Bioproductions programme, which is developing advanced consequential and prospective LCA methods to assess the environmental impacts of the transition to the bioeconomy.

This approach helps to inform strategic and policy decisions by anticipating the consequences of the large-scale roll-out of bio-based sectors.

Common misconception No. 5: LCA results are unreliable

False. LCA is a rigorous and transparent scientific method, governed by the international standards ISO 14040 and ISO 14044. It is based on a detailed description of methodological choices, inventories of material and energy flows, and the resulting assessment of environmental impacts. The reliability of its results depends on the quality of the data and the assumptions made.

The data comes in particular from socio-economic stakeholders (technical institutes, manufacturers, experts) and environmental databases. For example, a manufacturer knows how much energy their factory consumes to produce a certain number of units of goods, but is unaware of the impact of raw material extraction or transport. In France, the Agribalyse database run by ADEME is a key public resource on the environmental impacts of food and agricultural products.

Assumptions also play a key role: the boundaries of the system under study, the product’s lifespan, conditions of use, product performance and end-of-life scenarios.

An LCA does not yield a single score. Interpreting the results is an essential step in identifying the main sources of impact, taking account of uncertainties and understanding the limitations of the results to inform decision-making.

Conclusion: assessing the entire life cycle to make better decisions

A product’s environmental impact therefore depends neither solely on its carbon footprint nor on its bio-based origin. It results from a set of processes and choices that must be assessed as a whole.

LCA enables solutions to be compared and identifies impact shifts and levers for improvement. When complemented by a consequentialist approach, it helps to anticipate the effects of strategic decisions or policy choices.

Thanks to Eléonore Loiseau, LCA researcher at INRAE (UMR ITAP) and project lead for BIOCaP-LCA, for her contribution to the preparation of this article.